Representing the U.S. Men’s National Team is a unique honor and privilege that more than 850 individuals have earned in the team’s 100+ year history. In recognition of the small fraternity of athletes who have achieved this accomplishment, U.S. Soccer has assigned a “Unique Number” to each player that has played for the USMNT.
The Unique USMNT Number is determined by the order in which each player earned their first appearance for the National Team. There are a few considerations that detail how U.S. Soccer determines the Unique USMNT Player Number:
| Unique No. | Player | Date | Opponent |
| 1 | Neil Clarke | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 2 | Harry Cooper | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 3 | Charles Ellis | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 4 | James Ford | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 5 | Charles Harry Spalding | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 6 | John Hemingsley | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 7 | Thomas Murray | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 8 | James Robertson | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 9 | Clarence Smith | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 10 | Thomas Swords | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 11 | George Tintle | August 20, 1916 | Sweden |
| 12 | Matt Diedrichsen | September 3, 1916 | Norway |
| 13 | Aage Brix | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 14 | F. Burke Jones | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 15 | Sam Dalrymple | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 16 | Irving Davis | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 17 | Jimmy Douglas | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 18 | Henry Farrell | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 19 | William Findlay | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 20 | Raymond Hornberger | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 21 | Fred O'Conner | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 22 | Arthur Rudd | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 23 | Andy Straden | May 25, 1924 | Estonia |
| 24 | Carl Johnson | May 29, 1924 | Uruguay |
| 25 | Herbert Wells | May 29, 1924 | Uruguay |
| 26 | William Demko | June 10, 1924 | Poland |
| 27 | Edward Hart | June 10, 1924 | Poland |
| 28 | Jakes Mulholland | June 10, 1924 | Poland |
| 29 | James Rhody | June 16, 1924 | Ireland |
| 30 | Barney Battles | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 31 | Davey Brown | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 32 | Jock Ferguson | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 33 | Tom Florie | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 34 | Tommy McFarlane | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 35 | Henry Meyerdierks | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 36 | Robert Millar | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 37 | Archie Stark | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 38 | Tommy Stark | June 27, 1925 | Canada |
| 39 | Bill Carnihan | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 40 | Malcolm Goldie | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 41 | Willie Herd | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 42 | James Kelly | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 43 | Johnny McGuire | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 44 | David Robertson | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 45 | Tommy Steel | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 46 | Billy Wilson | November 8, 1925 | Canada |
| 47 | Andy Auld | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 48 | Gordon Burness | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 49 | Findlay Kerr | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 50 | Jack Marshall | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 51 | George Moorhouse | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 52 | Billy Morris | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 53 | Edmund Smith | November 6, 1926 | Canada |
| 54 | Robert Aitken | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 55 | Henry Carroll | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 56 | Albert Cooper | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 57 | John Deal | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 58 | John Duffy | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 59 | Jimmy Gallagher | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 60 | Rudy Kuntner | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 61 | Jack Lyons | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 62 | Francis Ryan | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 63 | Harry Smith | May 30, 1928 | Argentina |
| 64 | R. Allen Jr. | June 10, 1928 | Poland |
| 65 | James Brown | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 66 | Billy Gonsalves | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 67 | Bart McGhee | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 68 | Bert Patenaude | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 69 | Raphael Tracey | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 70 | Alexander Wood | July 13, 1930 | Belgium |
| 71 | Mike Bookie | August 17, 1930 | Brazil |
| 72 | Philip Slone | August 17, 1930 | Brazil |
| 73 | Ed Czerkiewicz | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 74 | Aldo Donelli | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 75 | Julius Hjulian | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 76 | William Lehman | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 77 | Willie McLean | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 78 | Werner Nilsen | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 79 | Peter Pietras | May 24, 1934 | Mexico |
| 80 | Walter Dick | May 27, 1934 | Italy |
| 81 | Charles Altemose | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 82 | Francis Bartkus | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 83 | James Crockett | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 84 | William Fiedler | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 85 | Andrew Gajda | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 86 | Frank Greinert | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 87 | Fred Lutkefedder | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 88 | George Nemchik | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 89 | Fred Zbilowski | August 3, 1936 | Italy |
| 90 | John Currie | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 91 | John Dubienny | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 92 | Thomson Ferrans | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 93 | Henry Margenson | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 94 | Joe Martinelli | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 95 | Sam McAlees | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 96 | John McEwan | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 97 | Alexander Rae | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 98 | Ed Ruddy | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 99 | Ray Voltz | September 12, 1937 | Mexico |
| 100 | Raymond Hamilton | September 19, 1937 | Mexico |
| 101 | Joseph Michaels | September 19, 1937 | Mexico |
| 102 | Angel Rodrigues | September 19, 1937 | Mexico |
| 103 | Jesse Braga | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 104 | Joe Ferreira | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 105 | Joe Machado | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 106 | Manuel Martin | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 107 | Frank Moniz | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 108 | Joseph Rego-Costa | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 109 | Walter Romanowicz | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 110 | Ed Souza | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 111 | John Souza | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 112 | John Travis | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 113 | Ed Valentine | July 13, 1947 | Mexico |
| 114 | Walter Bahr | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 115 | Raymond Beckman | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 116 | Bill Bertani | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 117 | Charlie Colombo | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 118 | Benny McLaughlin | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 119 | Archie Strimel | August 2, 1948 | Italy |
| 120 | Gino Pariani | August 6, 1948 | Norway |
| 121 | Robert Annis | August 11, 1948 | Northern Ireland |
| 122 | Steve Grivnow | August 11, 1948 | Northern Ireland |
| 123 | Herman Graesser | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 124 | Amiel Muniz | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 125 | John O'Connell | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 126 | Gene Olaff | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 127 | Bill Sheppell | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 128 | Howard Whatford | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 129 | Lou Yacopec | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 130 | Pete Matevich | June 19, 1949 | Scotland |
| 131 | Frank Borghi | September 4, 1949 | Mexico |
| 132 | Jack Hynes | September 4, 1949 | Mexico |
| 133 | Frank Wallace | September 4, 1949 | Mexico |
| 134 | Ben Wattman | September 4, 1949 | Mexico |
| 135 | Harry Keough | September 14, 1949 | Cuba |
| 136 | Joe Gaetjens | June 25, 1950 | Spain |
| 137 | Joe Maca | June 25, 1950 | Spain |
| 138 | Ed McIlvenny | June 25, 1950 | Spain |
| 139 | Adam Wolanin | June 25, 1950 | Spain |
| 140 | Lloyd Monsen | April 30, 1952 | Scotland |
| 141 | Richard Roberts | April 30, 1952 | Scotland |
| 142 | Bob Burkard | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 143 | Elwood Cook | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 144 | Ebby McHugh | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 145 | Ruben Mendoza | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 146 | Willie Schaller | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 147 | Larry Surrock | July 16, 1952 | Italy |
| 148 | George Athineos | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 149 | Efrain Chacurian | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 150 | Bill Connelly | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 151 | Rolf Decker | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 152 | Roy Milne | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 153 | Cecil Moore | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 154 | Tom Schultz | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 155 | Terry Springthorpe | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 156 | Otto Decker | June 8, 1953 | England |
| 157 | Cornelius Casey | January 10, 1954 | Mexico |
| 158 | Edward Embarger | January 10, 1954 | Mexico |
| 159 | William Looby | January 10, 1954 | Mexico |
| 160 | Donald Malinowski | January 14, 1954 | Mexico |
| 161 | Eugene Petramale | January 14, 1954 | Mexico |
| 162 | Bob Gormley | April 3, 1954 | Haiti |
| 163 | Herman Wecke | April 3, 1954 | Haiti |
| 164 | Robert Craddock | April 4, 1954 | Haiti |
| 165 | Alfonso Marina | August 25, 1955 | Iceland |
| 166 | Ed Murphy | August 25, 1955 | Iceland |
| 167 | Derek Nash | August 25, 1955 | Iceland |
| 168 | William Conterio | November 28, 1956 | Serbia |
| 169 | George Dorian | November 28, 1956 | Serbia |
| 170 | Svend Engedal | November 28, 1956 | Serbia |
| 171 | Zenon Snylyk | November 28, 1956 | Serbia |
| 172 | Al Zerhusen | November 28, 1956 | Serbia |
| 173 | George Brown | April 7, 1957 | Mexico |
| 174 | Gene Grabowski | April 7, 1957 | Mexico |
| 175 | John Peter Traina | April 7, 1957 | Mexico |
| 176 | James Hanna | April 28, 1957 | Mexico |
| 177 | Bud Lillie | April 28, 1957 | Mexico |
| 178 | Bill Eppy | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 179 | Leroy Franks | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 180 | James Murphy | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 181 | Russ Murphy | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 182 | Val Pelizzaro | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 183 | Bob Rooney | June 22, 1957 | Canada |
| 184 | Bob Whitehead | July 6, 1957 | Canada |
| 185 | Adolph Bachmeier | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 186 | Fred Cameron | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 187 | Willie Carson | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 188 | Ben Cinowitz | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 189 | Bert Evans | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 190 | Doug Farquhar | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 191 | Victor Ottobini | May 28, 1959 | England |
| 192 | Helmut Bicek | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 193 | Carl Fister | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 194 | Willy Freitag | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 195 | Eberhard Herz | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 196 | Joseph Krische | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 197 | Henry Noga | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 198 | Joe Speca | November 6, 1960 | Mexico |
| 199 | Alex Ely | November 13, 1960 | Mexico |
| 200 | Kenny Finn | November 13, 1960 | Mexico |
| 201 | Tony Bonezzi | February 5, 1961 | Colombia |
| 202 | Carlos Bustamente | February 5, 1961 | Colombia |
| 203 | Helmut Michel | February 5, 1961 | Colombia |
| 204 | Walter Ronge | February 5, 1961 | Colombia |
| 205 | Abbie Wolanow | February 5, 1961 | Colombia |
| 206 | Ivan Borodiak | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 207 | Walter Chyzowych | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 208 | Justo Garcia | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 209 | Charles Horvath | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 210 | Andy Mate | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 211 | Mike Noha | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 212 | Andy Racz | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 213 | Horst Rick | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 214 | Uwe Schwart | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 215 | Richard Wild | May 27, 1964 | England |
| 216 | Andy Cziotka | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 217 | Victor Gerley | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 218 | Bob Kehoe | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 219 | Cornell Krieger | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 220 | Tibor Resznecki | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 221 | Walt Schmotolocha | March 7, 1965 | Mexico |
| 222 | Willy Roy | March 12, 1965 | Mexico |
| 223 | Bayardo Abaunza | March 17, 1965 | Honduras |
| 224 | Josef Pal | March 17, 1965 | Honduras |
| 225 | Eddie Clear | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 226 | Gary DeLong | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 227 | Bob Gansler | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 228 | Carl Gentile | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 229 | Larry Hausemann | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 230 | Helmut Kofler | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 231 | Nick Krat | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 232 | Miguel Malizewski | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 233 | Peter Millar | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 234 | Janosz Benedek | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 235 | Tom Cecic | September 15, 1968 | Israel |
| 236 | Dietrich Albrecht | September 25, 1968 | Israel |
| 237 | Siegfried Stritzl | September 25, 1968 | Israel |
| 238 | Gene Tober | September 25, 1968 | Israel |
| 239 | Gerry Baker | October 13, 1968 | Canada |
| 240 | Sandy Feher | October 20, 1968 | Haiti |
| 241 | Alfred Kikel | October 21, 1968 | Haiti |
| 242 | Orest Banach | April 20, 1969 | Haiti |
| 243 | Werner Mata | April 20, 1969 | Haiti |
| 244 | Pat McBride | April 20, 1969 | Haiti |
| 245 | Barry Barto | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 246 | Gene Geimer | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 247 | Rudy Getzinger | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 248 | Alan Hamlyn | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 249 | Johnny Moore | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 250 | Gary Rensing | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 251 | Mike Winter | August 20, 1972 | Canada |
| 252-253 | Gary Barone | August 29, 1972 | Canada |
| 252-253 | Frederick Scardina | August 29, 1972 | Canada |
| 254 | Jorge Benitez | September 3, 1972 | Mexico |
| 255 | Werner Roth | September 3, 1972 | Mexico |
| 256 | Barney Djordjevic | September 10, 1972 | Mexico |
| 257 | Dieter Ficken | September 10, 1972 | Mexico |
| 258 | Fred Kovacs | September 10, 1972 | Mexico |
| 259 | Sergio Mora | September 10, 1972 | Mexico |
| 260 | John Best | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 261 | Dave Coskunian | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 262 | Steve Frank | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 263 | Doug McMillan | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 264 | Carlos Metidieri | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 265 | Jorge Siega | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 266-267 | Mike Ivanow | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 266-267 | Mike Renshaw | March 17, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 268 | Manfred Seissler | March 20, 1973 | Poland |
| 269 | Wally Ziaja | March 20, 1973 | Poland |
| 270 | Dan Califano | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 271 | Windsor Del Liano | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 272 | Emmanuel Georges | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 273 | Fred Grgurev | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 274 | Mark Liveric | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 275 | Art Martinich | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 276 | Jerry Panek | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 277 | Julio Servin | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 278 | Roy Turner | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 279-280 | Carmen Capurro | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 279-280 | Richard Green | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 281 | Bob O'Leary | August 3, 1973 | Poland |
| 282 | Paul Child | August 5, 1973 | Canada |
| 283 | Bill Deszofi | August 5, 1973 | Canada |
| 284 | Mick Hoban | August 5, 1973 | Canada |
| 285 | Stefan Shafer | August 5, 1973 | Canada |
| 286 | Cecil Correa | August 10, 1973 | Poland |
| 287 | Moe Hoffman | August 10, 1973 | Poland |
| 288 | Ilija Mitic | August 10, 1973 | Poland |
| 289 | Archie Roboostoff | August 10, 1973 | Poland |
| 290 | Buzz Demling | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 291 | Frank Ivic | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 292 | Charlie McCully | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 293 | Bobby Smith | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 294 | Al Trost | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 295 | Tony Francillo | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 296 | Kyle Rote | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 297 | Marko Vuckovic | August 12, 1973 | Poland |
| 298 | Ben Brewster | September 9, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 299 | Joey Fink | September 9, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 300 | Alain Maca | September 9, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 301 | Andy Rymarczuk | September 9, 1973 | Bermuda |
| 302 | Dick Hall | October 16, 1973 | Mexico |
| 303 | Barry Mahy | November 3, 1973 | Haiti |
| 304 | George O'Neill | November 3, 1973 | Haiti |
| 305 | Bob Rigby | November 3, 1973 | Haiti |
| 306 | Gordon Bradley | November 15, 1973 | Israel |
| 307 | Bruce Arena | November 15, 1973 | Israel |
| 308 | Dave D'Errico | September 5, 1974 | Mexico |
| 309 | Manny Hernandez | September 5, 1974 | Mexico |
| 310 | Bob Matteson | September 5, 1974 | Mexico |
| 311 | Denny Vaninger | September 5, 1974 | Mexico |
| 312 | Dan Counce | September 8, 1974 | Mexico |
| 313 | Paul Scurti | March 26, 1975 | Poland |
| 314 | Tom Galati | March 26, 1975 | Poland |
| 315 | Altino Domingues | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 316 | Mike Flater | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 317 | Randy Garber | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 318 | Hank Liotart | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 319 | Arnie Mausser | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 320 | Telmo Pires | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 321 | Doug Wark | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 322 | Tim Logush | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 323 | Kevin Welsh | June 24, 1975 | Poland |
| 324 | Peter Chandler | August 19, 1975 | Costa Rica |
| 325 | Henry McCully | August 19, 1975 | Costa Rica |
| 326 | Carlos Scott | August 19, 1975 | Costa Rica |
| 327 | Alex Skotarek | August 19, 1975 | Costa Rica |
| 328 | Bill Straub | August 19, 1975 | Costa Rica |
| 329 | Poli Garcia | August 21, 1975 | Argentina |
| 330 | Ed Kelly | August 21, 1975 | Argentina |
| 331 | Boris Bandov | September 24, 1976 | Canada |
| 332 | John Mason | September 24, 1976 | Canada |
| 333 | Steve Pecher | September 24, 1976 | Canada |
| 334 | Jim Pollihan | September 24, 1976 | Canada |
| 335 | Sam Bick | October 3, 1976 | Mexico |
| 336 | Neil Cohen | October 3, 1976 | Mexico |
| 337 | Dennis Wit | October 3, 1976 | Mexico |
| 338 | Santiago Formoso | October 3, 1976 | Mexico |
| 339 | Steve Ralbovsky | October 3, 1976 | Mexico |
| 340 | Juli Veee | October 15, 1976 | Mexico |
| 341 | Miro Rys | October 20, 1976 | Canada |
| 342 | Peter Dani | November 12, 1976 | Haiti |
| 343 | Alan Mayer | November 12, 1976 | Haiti |
| 344 | Rick Davis | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 345 | Tony Donlic | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 346 | Gary Etherington | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 347 | Glenn Myernick | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 348 | Jim McAlister | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 349 | Colin Fowles | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 350 | Fred Pereira | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 351 | Greg Villa | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 352 | Tony Bellinger | September 15, 1977 | El Salvador |
| 353 | Don Droege | September 18, 1977 | Guatemala |
| 354 | Ane Mihailovich | September 18, 1977 | Guatemala |
| 355 | George Nanchoff | September 18, 1977 | Guatemala |
| 356 | Miguel Lopez | September 27, 1977 | Mexico |
| 357 | Louis Nanchoff | September 6, 1978 | Switzerland |
| 358 | Greg Makowski | September 20, 1978 | Portugal |
| 359 | Dale Russell | September 20, 1978 | Portugal |
| 360 | Ty Keough | February 3, 1979 | Soviet Union |
| 361 | Bruce Rudroff | February 3, 1979 | Soviet Union |
| 362 | Angelo DiBernardo | February 3, 1979 | Soviet Union |
| 363 | Larry Hulcer | February 3, 1979 | Soviet Union |
| 364 | Tony Crudo | May 2, 1979 | France |
| 365 | Perry Van der Beck | May 2, 1979 | France |
| 366 | David Brcic | May 2, 1979 | France |
| 367 | John "Sonny" Askew | October 7, 1979 | Bermuda |
| 368 | Ringo Cantillo | October 7, 1979 | Bermuda |
| 369 | Doc Lawson | October 7, 1979 | Bermuda |
| 370-372 | Winston DuBose | October 7, 1979 | Bermuda |
| 370-372 | Pat Fidelia | October 7, 1979 | Bermuda |
| 370-372 | Njego Pesa | October 10, 1979 | France |
| 373 | Steve Moyers | October 5, 1980 | Luxembourg |
| 374 | Mark Peterson | October 5, 1980 | Luxembourg |
| 375 | Chico Borja | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 376 | Charlie Fajkus | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 377 | Tom O'Hara | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 378 | Derek Spalding | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 379 | Tim Twellman | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 380 | John Lignos | March 21, 1982 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 381 | Dan Canter | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 382 | Tony Crescitelli | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 383 | Pedro DeBrito | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 384 | Jeff Durgan | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 385 | Alan Merrick | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 386 | Bruce Savage | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 387 | Erhardt Kapp | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 388 | Rob Olson | April 8, 1983 | Haiti |
| 389 | Elvis Comrie | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 390 | Alan Green | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 391 | Andrew Parkinson | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 392 | Hugo Perez | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 393 | Gregg Thompson | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 394 | Kevin Crow | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 395 | Mike Fox | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 396 | Rudy Glenn | May 30, 1984 | Italy |
| 397 | Ade Coker | September 29, 1984 | Curacao |
| 398 | Chance Fry | October 6, 1984 | Curacao |
| 399 | Paul Caligiuri | October 9, 1984 | El Salvador |
| 400 | Jeff Hooker | October 9, 1984 | El Salvador |
| 401 | Jacques LaDouceur | October 9, 1984 | El Salvador |
| 402 | Steve Sharp | October 9, 1984 | El Salvador |
| 403 | Hayden Knight | October 11, 1984 | Colombia |
| 404 | Amr Aly | October 11, 1984 | Colombia |
| 405 | Billy Crook | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 406 | Mike Jeffries | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 407 | Mike Windischmann | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 408 | Michael Brady | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 409 | John Kerr | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 410 | Andy Papoulias | November 30, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 411 | Brian Bliss | December 2, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 412 | Eddie Hawkins | December 2, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 413 | Dave Cayemitte | December 2, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 414 | Jamie Swanner | December 2, 1984 | Ecuador |
| 415 | Ed Radwanski | February 8, 1985 | Switzerland |
| 416 | Paul DiBernardo | February 8, 1985 | Switzerland |
| 417-418 | Dale Ervine | April 2, 1985 | Canada |
| 417-418 | Jim Gorsek | April 2, 1985 | Canada |
| 419 | Bruce Murray | June 16, 1985 | England |
| 420 | Tim Harris | June 16, 1985 | England |
| 421 | Troy Snyder | June 16, 1985 | England |
| 422 | Jimmy Banks | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 423 | Eric Biefeld | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 424 | Eric Eichmann | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 425 | Brent Goulet | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 426 | Tom Kain | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 427 | Paul Krumpe | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 428 | Steve Sengelmann | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 429 | Tom Silvas | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 430 | John Stollmeyer | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 431 | David Vanole | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 432 | Sadri Gjonbalaj | February 5, 1986 | Canada |
| 433 | Desmond Armstrong | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 434 | John Doyle | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 435 | Ted Hantak | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 436 | John Harkes | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 437 | Steve Trittschuh | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 438 | Chris Sullivan | June 8, 1987 | Egypt |
| 439 | Joey Kirk | June 12, 1987 | Korea Republic |
| 440 | Jeff Duback | June 16, 1987 | Thailand |
| 441 | Jeff Agoos | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 442 | Marcelo Balboa | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 443 | Donald Cogsville | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 444 | Mike Constantino | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 445 | Steve Fuchs | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 446 | Kevin Grimes | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 447 | Tab Ramos | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 448 | Mark Santel | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 449 | Dan Smyth | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 450 | Mike Gregorian | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 451 | Lucas Martin | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 452 | John Diffley | January 10, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 453 | Mark Dodd | January 13, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 454 | Peter Vermes | January 13, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 455 | Ken Snow | January 13, 1988 | Guatemala |
| 456 | Jim Gabarra | May 14, 1988 | Colombia |
| 457 | Frank Klopas | May 14, 1988 | Colombia |
| 458 | Robin Fraser | June 1, 1988 | Chile |
| 459 | Bernie James | June 1, 1988 | Chile |
| 460 | George Pastor | June 1, 1988 | Chile |
| 461 | Arturo Velazco | June 1, 1988 | Chile |
| 462 | Neil Megson | June 1, 1988 | Chile |
| 463 | Michael Collins | June 5, 1988 | Chile |
| 464 | Ted Gillen | June 5, 1988 | Chile |
| 465 | Neil Covone | June 5, 1988 | Chile |
| 466 | Tony Meola | June 7, 1988 | Ecuador |
| 467 | Curt Onalfo | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 468 | Charlie Raphael | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 469 | Rob Ryerson | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 470 | Billy Thompson | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 471 | Zen Luzniak | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 472 | Steve Snow | June 14, 1988 | Costa Rica |
| 473 | Phillip Gyau | June 4, 1989 | Peru |
| 474 | Ted Eck | October 8, 1989 | Guatemala |
| 475 | Eric Wynalda | February 2, 1990 | Costa Rica |
| 476 | Kasey Keller | February 4, 1990 | Colombia |
| 477 | Jeff Baicher | February 13, 1990 | Bermuda |
| 478 | Chris Henderson | April 8, 1990 | Iceland |
| 479 | Dan Donigan | September 15, 1990 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 480 | Steve Pittman | September 15, 1990 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 481 | Troy Dayak | September 15, 1990 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 482 | Dominic Kinnear | November 18, 1990 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 483 | Fernando Clavijo | November 21, 1990 | Soviet Union |
| 484 | Earnie Stewart | December 19, 1990 | Portugal |
| 485 | Ronil Dufrene | February 1, 1991 | Switzerland |
| 486 | John DeBrito | February 21, 1991 | Bermuda |
| 487 | Alexi Lalas | March 12, 1991 | Mexico |
| 488 | Dante Washington | March 12, 1991 | Mexico |
| 489 | Janusz Michallik | May 5, 1991 | Uruguay |
| 490 | Brian Quinn | June 1, 1991 | Ireland |
| 491 | Jorge Acosta | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 492 | Mike Slivinski | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 493 | Brian Benedict | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 494 | Alberto Cruz | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 495 | Mark Jonas | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 496 | Nelson Vargas | September 14, 1991 | Jamaica |
| 497 | Roy Lassiter | January 25, 1992 | C.I.S. |
| 498 | Mike Sorber | January 25, 1992 | C.I.S. |
| 499 | Zak Ibsen | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 500 | Matt Kmosko | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 501 | Andy Strouse | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 502 | Carlos Jaguande | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 503 | Mark Chung | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 504 | Mirsad Huseinovic | February 12, 1992 | Costa Rica |
| 505 | Ian Feuer | March 18, 1992 | Morocco |
| 506 | Thomas Dooley | May 30, 1992 | Ireland |
| 507 | Roy Wegerle | May 30, 1992 | Ireland |
| 508 | Mike Masters | June 27, 1992 | Ukraine |
| 509 | Mike Burns | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 510 | Brad Friedel | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 511 | Cobi Jones | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 512 | Mike Lapper | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 513 | Joe-Max Moore | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 514 | Yari Allnutt | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 515 | Joey Leonetti | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 516 | Mike Gosselin | September 3, 1992 | Canada |
| 517 | Jean Harbor | October 9, 1992 | Canada |
| 518 | Peter Woodring | February 13, 1993 | Russia |
| 519 | Erik Imler | March 23, 1993 | El Salvador |
| 520 | Scoop Stanisic | March 23, 1993 | El Salvador |
| 521 | Alan Prampin | March 23, 1993 | El Salvador |
| 522 | Brian McBride | March 25, 1993 | Honduras |
| 523 | Cle Kooiman | May 26, 1993 | Peru |
| 524 | Chad Deering | October 13, 1993 | Mexico |
| 525 | Tim Martin | November 14, 1993 | Cayman Islands |
| 526 | Kevin Smith | November 14, 1993 | Cayman Islands |
| 527 | Dario Brose | January 15, 1994 | Norway |
| 528 | Claudio Reyna | January 15, 1994 | Norway |
| 529 | Juergen Sommer | September 7, 1994 | England |
| 530 | Lawrence Lozzano | October 19, 1994 | Saudi Arabia |
| 531 | Gregg Berhalter | October 19, 1994 | Saudi Arabia |
| 532 | Maurice Ligeon | October 19, 1994 | Saudi Arabia |
| 533 | Jovan Kirovski | October 19, 1994 | Saudi Arabia |
| 534 | Marcus Hahnemann | November 19, 1994 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 535 | Jorge Salcedo | November 19, 1994 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 536 | Jason Dunn | November 19, 1994 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 537 | Zach Thornton | November 22, 1994 | Jamaica |
| 538 | Paul Bravo | December 11, 1994 | Honduras |
| 539 | Ante Razov | March 25, 1995 | Uruguay |
| 540 | David Quesada | May 28, 1995 | Costa Rica |
| 541 | Jason Kreis | August 30, 1996 | El Salvador |
| 542 | David Wagner | August 30, 1996 | El Salvador |
| 543 | Frankie Hejduk | August 30, 1996 | El Salvador |
| 544 | Miles Joseph | August 30, 1996 | El Salvador |
| 545 | Scott Benedetti | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 546 | Jorge Flores | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 547 | Tayt Ianni | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 548 | Eddie Lewis | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 549 | Mac Cozier | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 550 | Paul Holocher | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 551 | Ramiro Corrales | October 16, 1996 | Peru |
| 552 | Preki Radosavljevic | November 3, 1996 | Guatemala |
| 553 | Eddie Pope | November 10, 1996 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 554 | Martin Vasquez | December 21, 1996 | Guatemala |
| 555 | Greg Vanney | December 21, 1996 | Guatemala |
| 556 | Steve Ralston | January 17, 1997 | Peru |
| 557 | Dan Calichman | January 19, 1997 | Mexico |
| 558 | Tony Sanneh | January 29, 1997 | China PR |
| 559 | Michael Mason | March 16, 1997 | Canada |
| 560 | Brian Maisonneuve | June 4, 1997 | Paraguay |
| 561 | Ted Chronopoulos | June 17, 1997 | Israel |
| 562 | John O'Brien | April 22, 1998 | Austria |
| 563 | David Regis | May 24, 1998 | Kuwait |
| 564 | Carlos Llamosa | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 565 | Clint Mathis | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 566 | Richie Williams | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 567 | Chris Armas | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 568 | Ben Olsen | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 569 | C.J. Brown | November 6, 1998 | Australia |
| 570 | Imad Baba | January 25, 1999 | Bolivia |
| 571 | Tom Presthus | February 21, 1999 | Chile |
| 572 | Leo Cullen | February 21, 1999 | Chile |
| 573 | Matt McKeon | July 30, 1999 | Germany |
| 574 | Steve Cherundolo | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 575 | Henry Gutierrez | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 576 | Kevin Hartman | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 577 | Josh Wolff | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 578 | Chad McCarty | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 579 | Chris Albright | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 580 | Billy Walsh | September 8, 1999 | Jamaica |
| 581 | Brian West | April 26, 2000 | Russia |
| 582 | Chris Klein | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 583 | Kerry Zavagnin | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 584 | Landon Donovan | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 585 | Joe Franchino | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 586 | Peter Vagenas | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 587 | Sasha Victorine | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 588 | Bobby Convey | October 25, 2000 | Mexico |
| 589 | DaMarcus Beasley | January 27, 2001 | China PR |
| 590 | Mike Petke | June 7, 2001 | Ecuador |
| 591 | Pablo Mastroeni | June 7, 2001 | Ecuador |
| 592 | Joe Enochs | June 7, 2001 | Ecuador |
| 593 | John Thorrington | June 7, 2001 | Ecuador |
| 594 | Jesse Marsch | November 11, 2001 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 595 | Diego Gutierrez | December 9, 2001 | Korea Republic |
| 596 | Manny Lagos | December 9, 2001 | Korea Republic |
| 597 | Carlos Bocanegra | December 9, 2001 | Korea Republic |
| 598 | Jeff Cunningham | December 9, 2001 | Korea Republic |
| 599 | Richard Mulrooney | December 9, 2001 | Korea Republic |
| 600 | Danny Califf | January 19, 2002 | Korea Republic |
| 601 | Tim Howard | March 10, 2002 | Ecuador |
| 602 | Wade Barrett | November 17, 2002 | El Salvador |
| 603 | Taylor Twellman | November 17, 2002 | El Salvador |
| 604 | Nick Rimando | November 17, 2002 | El Salvador |
| 605 | Kyle Martino | November 17, 2002 | El Salvador |
| 606 | Nick Garcia | January 18, 2003 | Canada |
| 607 | Edson Buddle | March 29, 2003 | Venezuela |
| 608 | Ryan Suarez | May 26, 2003 | Wales |
| 609 | Brian Ching | May 26, 2003 | Wales |
| 610 | Alecko Eskandarian | May 26, 2003 | Wales |
| 611 | Joe Cannon | June 8, 2003 | New Zealand |
| 612 | Cory Gibbs | June 8, 2003 | New Zealand |
| 613 | Jonny Walker | January 18, 2004 | Denmark |
| 614 | John Wolyniec | January 18, 2004 | Denmark |
| 615 | Pat Noonan | March 13, 2004 | Haiti |
| 616 | Conor Casey | March 31, 2004 | Poland |
| 617 | Brian Mullan | July 11, 2004 | Poland |
| 618 | Eddie Gaven | July 11, 2004 | Poland |
| 619 | Eddie Johnson | October 9, 2004 | El Salvador |
| 620 | Oguchi Onyewu | October 13, 2004 | Panama |
| 621 | Clint Dempsey | November 17, 2004 | Jamaica |
| 622 | Jonathan Spector | November 17, 2004 | Jamaica |
| 623 | Jon Busch | March 9, 2005 | Colombia |
| 624 | Ritchie Kotschau | March 9, 2005 | Colombia |
| 625 | Chad Marshall | March 9, 2005 | Colombia |
| 626 | Nat Borchers | March 9, 2005 | Colombia |
| 627 | Clyde Simms | May 28, 2005 | England |
| 628 | Jimmy Conrad | July 7, 2005 | Cuba |
| 629 | Brad Davis | July 7, 2005 | Cuba |
| 630 | Santino Quaranta | July 7, 2005 | Cuba |
| 631 | Brian Carroll | October 12, 2005 | Panama |
| 632 | Justin Mapp | October 12, 2005 | Panama |
| 633 | Ricardo Clark | October 12, 2005 | Panama |
| 634 | Chris Rolfe | November 12, 2005 | Scotland |
| 635 | Heath Pearce | November 12, 2005 | Scotland |
| 636 | Matt Reis | January 22, 2006 | Canada |
| 637 | Freddy Adu | January 22, 2006 | Canada |
| 638 | Todd Dunivant | January 29, 2006 | Norway |
| 639 | Nate Jaqua | January 29, 2006 | Norway |
| 640 | Ugo Ihemelu | January 29, 2006 | Norway |
| 641 | Brad Guzan | February 19, 2006 | Guatemala |
| 642 | Bobby Boswell | February 19, 2006 | Guatemala |
| 643 | Zach Wells | February 19, 2006 | Guatemala |
| 644 | Michael Bradley | May 26, 2006 | Venezuela |
| 645 | Jonathan Bornstein | January 20, 2007 | Denmark |
| 646 | Kenny Cooper | January 20, 2007 | Denmark |
| 647 | Bryan Namoff | January 20, 2007 | Denmark |
| 648 | Kyle Beckerman | January 20, 2007 | Denmark |
| 649 | Joshua Gros | February 7, 2007 | Mexico |
| 650 | Benny Feilhaber | March 25, 2007 | Ecuador |
| 651 | Jay DeMerit | March 28, 2007 | Guatemala |
| 652 | Frank Simek | March 28, 2007 | Guatemala |
| 653 | Sacha Kljestan | June 2, 2007 | China PR |
| 654 | Charlie Davies | June 2, 2007 | China PR |
| 655 | Kamani Hill | June 2, 2007 | China PR |
| 656 | Lee Nguyen | June 2, 2007 | China PR |
| 657 | Michael Parkhurst | June 9, 2007 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 658 | Marvell Wynne | June 28, 2007 | Argentina |
| 659 | Herculez Gomez | June 28, 2007 | Argentina |
| 660 | Drew Moor | July 2, 2007 | Paraguay |
| 661 | Sal Zizzo | August 22, 2007 | Sweden |
| 662 | Davy Arnaud | September 9, 2007 | Brazil |
| 663 | Maurice Edu | October 17, 2007 | Switzerland |
| 664 | Danny Szetela | October 17, 2007 | Switzerland |
| 665 | Robbie Findley | October 17, 2007 | Switzerland |
| 666 | Jozy Altidore | November 17, 2007 | South Africa |
| 667 | Eddie Robinson | January 19, 2008 | Sweden |
| 668 | Clarence Goodson | January 19, 2008 | Sweden |
| 669 | Jeremiah White | January 19, 2008 | Sweden |
| 670 | Chad Barrett | June 22, 2008 | Barbados |
| 671 | Jose Torres | October 11, 2008 | Cuba |
| 672 | Michael Orozco | October 15, 2008 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 673 | Troy Perkins | January 24, 2009 | Sweden |
| 674 | Robbie Rogers | January 24, 2009 | Sweden |
| 675 | Chris Wingert | January 24, 2009 | Sweden |
| 676 | Stuart Holden | July 4, 2009 | Grenada |
| 677 | Logan Pause | July 4, 2009 | Grenada |
| 678 | Brad Evans | July 4, 2009 | Grenada |
| 679 | Colin Clark | July 11, 2009 | Haiti |
| 680 | Sam Cronin | July 11, 2009 | Haiti |
| 681 | Jay Heaps | July 11, 2009 | Haiti |
| 682 | Luis Robles | July 11, 2009 | Haiti |
| 683 | Dax McCarty | November 14, 2009 | Slovakia |
| 684 | Edgar Castillo | November 18, 2009 | Denmark |
| 685 | Alejandro Bedoya | January 23, 2010 | Honduras |
| 686 | Geoff Cameron | February 24, 2010 | El Salvador |
| 687 | Omar Gonzalez | August 10, 2010 | Brazil |
| 688 | Jermaine Jones | October 9, 2010 | Poland |
| 689 | Brek Shea | October 12, 2010 | Colombia |
| 690 | Eric Lichaj | October 12, 2010 | Colombia |
| 691 | Tim Ream | November 17, 2010 | South Africa |
| 692 | Teal Bunbury | November 17, 2010 | South Africa |
| 693 | Juan Agudelo | November 17, 2010 | South Africa |
| 694 | Mix Diskerud | November 17, 2010 | South Africa |
| 695 | Gale Agbossoumonde | November 17, 2010 | South Africa |
| 696 | Sean Franklin | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 697 | Jeff Larentowicz | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 698 | Zach Loyd | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 699 | Chris Wondolowski | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 700 | Sean Johnson | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 701 | Anthony Wallace | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 702 | Eric Alexander | January 22, 2011 | Chile |
| 703 | Timmy Chandler | March 26, 2011 | Argentina |
| 704 | David Yelldell | March 29, 2011 | Paraguay |
| 705 | Danny Williams | October 8, 2011 | Honduras |
| 706 | Fabian Johnson | November 11, 2011 | France |
| 707 | A.J. DeLaGarza | January 21, 2012 | Venezuela |
| 708 | Bill Hamid | January 21, 2012 | Venezuela |
| 709 | Graham Zusi | January 21, 2012 | Venezuela |
| 710 | C.J. Sapong | January 21, 2012 | Venezuela |
| 711 | Jeff Parke | January 25, 2012 | Panama |
| 712 | Terrence Boyd | February 29, 2012 | Italy |
| 713 | Joe Corona | May 26, 2012 | Scotland |
| 714 | Alan Gordon | October 12, 2012 | Antigua & Barbuda |
| 715 | Joshua Gatt | November 14, 2012 | Russia |
| 716 | Tony Beltran | January 29, 2013 | Canada |
| 717 | Matt Besler | January 29, 2013 | Canada |
| 718 | Justin Morrow | January 29, 2013 | Canada |
| 719 | Will Bruin | January 29, 2013 | Canada |
| 720 | Alfredo Morales | January 29, 2013 | Canada |
| 721 | John Brooks | August 14, 2013 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 722 | Aron Johannsson | August 14, 2013 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 723 | Bobby Wood | August 14, 2013 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 724 | DeAndre Yedlin | February 1, 2014 | Korea Republic |
| 725 | Luis Gil | February 1, 2014 | Korea Republic |
| 726 | Julian Green | April 2, 2014 | Mexico |
| 727 | Joe Gyau | September 3, 2014 | Czech Republic |
| 728 | Greg Garza | September 3, 2014 | Czech Republic |
| 729 | Emerson Hyndman | September 3, 2014 | Czech Republic |
| 730 | Miguel Ibarra | October 14, 2014 | Honduras |
| 731 | Rubio Rubin | November 14, 2014 | Colombia |
| 732 | Jordan Morris | November 18, 2014 | Ireland |
| 733 | Steve Birnbaum | January 28, 2015 | Chile |
| 734 | Wil Trapp | January 28, 2015 | Chile |
| 735 | Gyasi Zardes | January 28, 2015 | Chile |
| 736 | Perry Kitchen | February 8, 2015 | Panama |
| 737 | Matt Hedges | February 8, 2015 | Panama |
| 738 | Ventura Alvarado | March 25, 2015 | Denmark |
| 739 | William Yarbrough | March 31, 2015 | Switzerland |
| 740 | Andrew Wooten | October 13, 2015 | Costa Rica |
| 741 | Darlington Nagbe | November 13, 2015 | St. Vincent and the Grenadines |
| 742 | Matt Miazga | November 13, 2015 | St. Vincent and the Grenadines |
| 743 | Kellyn Acosta | January 31, 2016 | Iceland |
| 744 | Ethan Finlay | January 31, 2016 | Iceland |
| 745 | Tony Tchani | January 31, 2016 | Iceland |
| 746 | Jerome Kiesewetter | January 31, 2016 | Iceland |
| 747 | David Bingham | February 5, 2016 | Canada |
| 748 | Brandon Vincent | February 5, 2016 | Canada |
| 749 | Christian Pulisic | March 29, 2016 | Guatemala |
| 750 | Paul Arriola | May 22, 2016 | Puerto Rico |
| 751 | Fafa Picault | May 22, 2016 | Puerto Rico |
| 752 | Caleb Stanko | September 6, 2016 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 753 | Ethan Horvath | October 7, 2016 | Cuba |
| 754 | Lynden Gooch | October 11, 2016 | New Zealand |
| 755 | Sebastian Lletget | January 29, 2017 | Serbia |
| 756 | Chris Pontius | January 29, 2017 | Serbia |
| 757 | Jorge Villafaña | January 29, 2017 | Serbia |
| 758 | Walker Zimmerman | February 3, 2017 | Jamaica |
| 759 | Dom Dwyer | July 1, 2017 | Ghana |
| 760 | Kelyn Rowe | July 1, 2017 | Ghana |
| 761 | Kenny Saief | July 1, 2017 | Ghana |
| 762 | Cristian Roldan | July 12, 2017 | Martinique |
| 763 | Tyler Adams | November 14, 2017 | Portugal |
| 764 | Weston McKennie | November 14, 2017 | Portugal |
| 765 | Cameron Carter-Vickers | November 14, 2017 | Portugal |
| 766 | Ike Opara | January 28, 2018 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 767 | Matt Polster | January 28, 2018 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 768 | Zack Steffen | January 28, 2018 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 769 | Marky Delgado | March 27, 2018 | Paraguay |
| 770 | Andrija Novakovich | March 27, 2018 | Paraguay |
| 771 | Tim Weah | March 27, 2018 | Paraguay |
| 772 | Alex Bono | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 773 | Erik Palmer-Brown | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 774 | Antonee Robinson | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 775 | Josh Sargent | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 776 | Keaton Parks | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 777 | Matt Olosunde | May 28, 2018 | Bolivia |
| 778 | Tim Parker | June 2, 2018 | Ireland |
| 779 | Shaq Moore | June 2, 2018 | Ireland |
| 780 | Luca de la Torre | June 2, 2018 | Ireland |
| 781 | Ben Sweat | October 11, 2018 | Colombia |
| 782 | Jonathon Amon | October 16, 2018 | Peru |
| 783 | Reggie Cannon | October 16, 2018 | Peru |
| 784 | Aaron Long | October 16, 2018 | Peru |
| 785 | Romain Gall | November 20, 2018 | Italy |
| 786 | Corey Baird | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 787 | Jeremy Ebobisse | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 788 | Nick Lima | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 789 | Daniel Lovitz | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 790 | Djordje Mihailovic | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 791 | Jonathan Lewis | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 792 | Christian Ramirez | January 27, 2019 | Panama |
| 793 | Jackson Yueill | June 5, 2019 | Jamaica |
| 794 | Duane Holmes | June 5, 2019 | Jamaica |
| 795 | Tyler Boyd | June 9, 2019 | Venezuela |
| 796 | Sergiño Dest | September 6, 2019 | Mexico |
| 797 | Miles Robinson | September 6, 2019 | Mexico |
| 798 | Paxton Pomykal | September 10, 2019 | Uruguay |
| 799 | Brenden Aaronson | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 800 | Jesús Ferreira | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 801 | Ulysses Llanez | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 802 | Sam Vines | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 803 | Mark McKenzie | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 804 | Brandon Servania | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 805 | Chase Gasper | February 1, 2020 | Costa Rica |
| 806 | Konrad de la Fuente | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 807 | Yunus Musah | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 808 | Gio Reyna | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 809 | Johnny Cardoso | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 810 | Nicholas Gioacchini | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 811 | Owen Otasowie | November 12, 2020 | Wales |
| 812 | Richy Ledezma | November 16, 2020 | Panama |
| 813 | Sebastian Soto | November 16, 2020 | Panama |
| 814 | Chris Richards | November 16, 2020 | Panama |
| 815 | Ayo Akinola | December 9, 2020 | El Salvador |
| 816 | Julian Araujo | December 9, 2020 | El Salvador |
| 817 | Chris Mueller | December 9, 2020 | El Salvador |
| 818 | Marco Farfan | December 9, 2020 | El Salvador |
| 819 | Kyle Duncan | December 9, 2020 | El Salvador |
| 820 | Aaron Herrera | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 821 | Matt Turner | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 822 | Andrés Perea | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 823 | George Bello | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 824 | Daryl Dike | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 825 | Tanner Tessmann | January 31, 2021 | Trinidad & Tobago |
| 826 | Jordan Pefok | March 25, 2021 | Jamaica |
| 827 | Bryan Reynolds | March 28, 2021 | Northern Ireland |
| 828 | Gianluca Busio | July 11, 2021 | Haiti |
| 829 | Eryk Williamson | July 11, 2021 | Haiti |
| 830 | James Sands | July 11, 2021 | Haiti |
| 831 | Matthew Hoppe | July 15, 2021 | Martinique |
| 832 | Donovan Pines | July 15, 2021 | Martinique |
| 833 | Henry Kessler | August 1, 2021 | Mexico |
| 834 | Ricardo Pepi | September 8, 2021 | Honduras |
| 835 | Brooks Lennon | December 18, 2021 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 836 | Cole Bassett | December 18, 2021 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 837 | Cade Cowell | December 18, 2021 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 838 | Jonathan Gómez | December 18, 2021 | Bosnia-Herzegovina |
| 839 | Joe Scally | June 1, 2022 | Morocco |
| 840 | Haji Wright | June 1, 2022 | Morocco |
| 841 | Malik Tillman | June 1, 2022 | Morocco |
| 842 | Julian Gressel | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 843 | Aidan Morris | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 844 | Jalen Neal | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 845 | Gaga Slonina | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 846 | Alan Soñora | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 847 | Brandon Vazquez | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 848 | Alex Zendejas | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 849 | DeJuan Jones | January 25, 2023 | Serbia |
| 850 | Paxten Aaronson | January 28, 2023 | Colombia |
| 851 | John Tolkin | January 28, 2023 | Colombia |
| 852 | Emmanuel Sabbi | January 28, 2023 | Colombia |
| 853 | Sam Rogers | January 28, 2023 | Colombia |
| 854 | Auston Trusty | March 24, 2023 | Grenada |
| 855 | Taylor Booth | March 24, 2023 | Grenada |
| 856 | Caleb Wiley | April 19, 2023 | Mexico |
| 857 | Folarin Balogun | June 15, 2023 | Mexico |
| 858 | Kristoffer Lund | September 9, 2023 | Uzbekistan |
| 859 | Ben Cremaschi | September 12, 2023 | Oman |
| 860 | Kevin Paredes | September 12, 2023 | Oman |
| 861 | Lenny Maloney | October 17, 2023 | Ghana |
| 862 | Josh Atencio | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 863 | Bernard Kamungo | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 864 | Diego Luna | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 865 | Patrick Schulte | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 866 | Timmy Tillman | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 867 | Brian White | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 868 | Sean Zawadzki | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 869 | Jack McGlynn | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 870 | Esmir Bajraktarevic | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 871 | Duncan McGuire | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 872 | Aziel Jackson | January 20, 2024 | Slovenia |
| 873 | Marlon Fossey | September 10, 2024 | New Zealand |